1. The Signs of the Appearance (Zuhur) of the Mahdi
2. The Destiny of the Unbelievers
3. The Destiny of Jews and Christians
4. Will the Majority of the Peoples on the Earth Be Killed?
5. The Teachings of Islam Will Be Proclaimed to the World from Qumm
6. "Your Enemies Will Destroy Each Other"
7. War Is Inevitable
8. The Mahdi's Defense
9. The World under the Mahdi
10. The Victory of the Prophets
11. The Mahdi and the New Constitution
12. The Conduct of the Mahdi
13. The Freshness of the Explanations Offered by the Mahdi
14. The Mahdi and Abrogation of the Ordinances
15. Is It Not Possible that the Mahdi Has Already Appeared?
16. Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad Shirazi, "the Bab"
17. Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad's Acknowledgement of the Hidden Imam's Existence
18. Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad and the Traditions about Fixing of the Time
19. What Do the Sayyid's Followers Say?
20. The Bayan and Messianic Claim
21. False Claims and the Existence of a Followership
The Signs of the Appearance (Zuhur) of the Mahdi
The session began promptly at 8 p.m. at Dr. Jalali's residence. He also opened the session by asking the first question.
Dr. Jalali: Mr. Hoshyar could you please tell us how will the Master of the Command appear?
Mr. Hoshyar: On studying the hadith reported by the ahl al-bayt it appears that when the world has become psychologically ready to accept the government of God and when general conditions have become favorable to the idea of the rulership of the truth God will permit the Mahdi to launch his final revolution. He will suddenly appear in Mecca and the caller of God will announce to the world that he has alighted. A few selected individuals whose number has been fixed to 313 in some traditions will be the first ones to respond to his call and will be drawn to him like iron to a magnet in that first hour of his appearance.
Imam Sadiq relates: "When the Master of the Age appears the young among his followers (shi'a) without any prior appointment will rouse themselves and reach Mecca that very night."
At that time the Mahdi will call upon the entire world to join his movement. Those who have suffered and lost all hope that their situation could improve will rally around him and will pay allegiance to him. In a short time a vast army made up of courageous sacrificing and reform-seeking peoples of the world will be prepared to be led by him. Imams Baqir and Sadiq (peace be upon them) have described the Qa'im's helpers thus:
They will occupy the east and the west of the world will bring everything under his command. Each one of these soldiers will have the power of forty strong men. Their hearts will be harder than iron pieces so much so that in their march to the goal should they encounter mountains made of iron they will overcome them with their inner strength. They will continue their struggle until God's pleasure is acquired. 
At that time the imperious sinful rulers lacking any conscience yet sensing the threat would come out in defense calling out the oppositional forces made up of their own followers. But the soldiers of justice and reform having been disgusted with the injustice and persecution of those evil forces will take the ultimate decision of attacking them in unison and with total effort. With God's help and sanction they will wipe them out. Awe and fear will descend upon the survivors who will finally surrender to the rightful just government.
On seeing the fulfillment of many of the signs promised in the traditions a large number of unbelievers will turn towards Islam. Those who persist in their disbelief and wickedness shall be killed by the soldiers of the Mahdi. The only victorious government in the entire world will be that of Islam and people will devotedly endeavor to protect it. Islam will be the religion of everyone and will enter all the nations of the world.
The Destiny of the Unbelievers
Dr. Jalali: What will happen to the unbelievers (kuffar) and those who associated partners with God (mushrikin)?
Mr. Hoshyar: From the readings in the Qur'an and the hadith literature it appears that during the Mahdi's rule the government and the power will be taken away from non-monotheistic and materialistic disbelievers and will be vested in the hands of the Muslims and other worthy people of the world. Let us for example look at certain verses from the Qur'an:
It is He who has sent His Messenger with the guidance and the religion of truth that he may uplift it above every religion though the unbelievers be averse. (Saff  9)
God has promised those of you who believe and do righteous deeds that He will surely make you successors in the land even as He made those who were before them successors and that He will surely establish their religion for them that He has approved for them and will give them in exchange after their fear security: 'They shall serve Me not associating with Me anything.' (Nur  54)
Yet We desired to be gracious to those that were abased in the land and to make them leaders and to make them the inheritors and to establish them in the land. (Qasas  4)
These passages from the Qur'an give the glad tidings of that which will come when world power and government are in the hands of the qualified and worthy believers and Muslims and the religion of Islam ("submission to the will of God") overshadows all other religions and actually eclipses them all.
The traditions speak about the period of the Mahdi's rule and assure the believers that the forces of disbelief and hypocrisy will be annihilated from the face of the earth. Everywhere there will be a true believer in God's unity. Thus for example the Prophet (peace be upon him and his progeny) said:
Even if there remains one day in the life of the earth God will bring forth a man from among my progeny whose name and character will be like mine and whose patronymic will be Abu 'Abd Allah. Through him God will revive His religion and bring it back to its early glory. God will also endow him with victory and there will remain on earth none other than the ones who will declare the Unity of God (tawhid).
The Prophet was asked as to which of his children's descendants he would be. The Prophet struck his hand on Husayn and said: "From his [descendants]."
Imam Baqir has related a hadith in which he says: "The Qa'im and his companions will fight so much that there will no longer be those unbelievers who associate partners to God."
The Destiny of Jews and Christians
Dr. Jalali: Since Jews and Christians are the followers of the heavenly books that teach monotheism what will happen to them when the Mahdi appears?
Mr. Hoshyar: The apparent sense of some of the verses of the Qur'an seems to suggest that they will be around until the Day of Judgement occurs. God says in the Sura Ma'ida 14:
And with those who say 'We are Christians' We took compact; and they have forgotten a portion of that they were reminded of. So We have stirred up among them enmity and hatred till the Day of Resurrection.
In the Sura Al 'Imran 55 He says:
When God said 'Jesus I will take thee to Me and I will purify thee of those who believe not. I will set thy followers above the unbelievers till the Resurrection Day.'
Again in Sura Ma'ida 64 He says:
The Jews have said: 'God's hand is fettered.' Fettered are their hands and they are cursed for what they have said. Nay but His hands are outspread; He expends how He will. And what has been sent down to thee from Thy Lord will surely increase many of them in insolence and unbelief; and We have cast between them enmity and hatred till the Day of Resurrection.
As you can see the literal reading of these verses suggests that the religions of the Jews and the Christians will be around until the Day of Judgement. Some of the hadith-reports corroborate this observation. Thus for instance Abu Basir asked Imam Sadiq: "What will the Master of the Command do to the 'protected peoples' (ahl al-dhimma)?" The Imam said: "Like the Prophet he will negotiate terms with them and they will pay the jizya (poll tax) while accepting their inferior position [in the Muslim society]."
In another tradition Imam Baqir says:
The Master of the Command was named as the Mahdi because he will dig out the Torah and other heavenly books from the cave in Antioch. He will judge among the people of the Torah according to the Torah; among the people of the Gospel according to the Gospel; among the people of the Psalms in accordance with the Psalms; among the people of the Qur'an in accordance with the Qur'an.
There are traditions that speak just the opposite of what the Qur'an and above-cited hadith speak. These traditions relate that during the rule of the Mahdi there will no other communities except the Muslims. The Mahdi will offer the religion of Islam to the Jews and the Christians; if they accept it they will be spared otherwise they will be killed. Thus for example the following tradition in which Ibn Bukayr asks Imam Rida the interpretation of the verse: "To Him submits everything that is in the heavens and the earth in obedience and in aversion." The Imam relates:
The particular verse is revealed in reference to the Qa'im. When he appears he will offer the religion of Islam to the Jews Christians Sabians and the disbelievers in the east and the west. Any one who willingly accepts Islam will be asked to pray give alms and perform all the obligatory acts; and any one who refuses to do so will be killed. This will continue until there remains none but a believer in and worshipper of One God everywhere on the earth.
Ibn Bukayr said to the Imam that in that case there would be far too many people who would be killed. The Imam said: "Whenever God desires something to increase or decrease He can do so."
In another tradition Imam Baqir related that God will open the east and the west for the twelfth Imam. He will put up the fight until there is no other religion than the religion of Muhammad. In his commentary on the verse that says: "He (God) will manifest it (Islam) even if the disbelievers are averse to it " The Imam said: "He will do it in such a way that there will be no one left except that he will have accepted the religion of Muhammad."
Hence there are two kinds of hadith: one in favor and the other objecting. However it must be pointed out that those traditions that agree with the Qur'an have preponderance over those that do not and therefore the latter must be of necessity rejected as unreliable. Accordingly the Jews and the Christians will remain under the government of the twelfth Imam but they will have abandoned their belief in the trinity and all forms of disbelief connected with associating partners to God and become worshippers of One God. They will continue to live under the protection of the Islamic government. At the same time the corrupt and tyrannical governments will come to an end and power will be exercised by the well qualified Muslims. Islam will be the world's religion gaining precedence over all other religions and the call of the Unity of God (tawhid) will be heard all across the world. In this connection Imam Sadiq has said: "When our Qa'im rises there is no place on earth where one will not hear the testimony: I bear witness that there is no deity except God and Muhammad is the Messenger of God." According to Imam Baqir: "When the Qa'im takes the command all the godless governments will become permanently extinct." Furthermore in explaining the verse "when they will be consolidated they will establish worship and give alms " the Imam said: "This verse was revealed to describe the Imams the Mahdi and his loyal followers. God will make them the commanders of the east and the west and through them God will fortify the religion and eliminate innovation and false [interpretations in it]. Indeed the ignorant people have ruined the truth. All this will be accomplished in such a way that there shall remain no trace of injustice. He will execute the duty of commanding the good and forbidding the evil."
In another report Abu Basir says that he asked Imam Sadiq: "Who is the Qa'im of the ahl al-bayt?" He said:
O Abu Basir he will be the fifth descendant of my son Musa the son of the best among the slave girls. His occultation will be prolonged so much so that a group will fall into doubt. Afterwards God will cause him to appear and will make him conquer the entire world. Jesus the son of Mary will descend [from heaven] and will perform his prayer standing behind him. In that afternoon the earth will brighten up with the Light of God and all spots on earth where other than God was worshipped will become a prayer house dedicated to God. Religion will be entirely God's even though the disbelievers may be averse to it. 
Engineer Madani: I recall another related topic but since the time is running short I will raise it when we meet next time.
The session was concluded for that evening and it was decided that the group would meet in a week's time at Dr. Jalali's residence.
The meeting started promptly at Dr. Jalali's place. It was indeed gratifying to know the number of issues related to the subject of the twelfth Imam (peace be upon him) that were raised discussed and critically analyzed in the sessions that had met so far. The next important issue was the destiny of other peoples under the government of the Mahdi.
Will the Majority of the Peoples on the Earth Be Killed?
Engineer Madani: As you all are aware Muslims today are a minority in the world. The sizeable majority inhabiting the planet is non-Muslim. The Shi'a are also a minority in comparison to other schools of thought among Muslims. Among the Shi'a it must be pointed out in all honesty there are many evildoers and corrupt people. On the basis of the way things move in a society in addition to some analogical deduction this religious scene of the world is unlikely to change drastically. It is possible to speculate that at the time when the Mahdi appears the Shi'a will still be a minority. My question is this: Is it logical and credible to maintain that the majority of the world's population will simply submit and will not resist as they are being eliminated by the soldiers of the Imam of the Age? Moreover if the majority of the inhabitants of the world are going to be killed then this earth will look like a huge cemetery. Does it mean then that the Shi'a will rule over this large cemetery? Surely this action cannot be identified as an act of reform and such a government as the universal authority!
Mr. Hoshyar: Actually we do not have sufficient information about the future world. We cannot speculate about the future on the basis of the past. The Muslim assessment of the situation about the human condition is that humanity is already in a state of perfection in terms of capability and mentality. With the Mahdi's revolution they will be even more prepared to accept the truth.
We often hear that many intellectuals in the east and the west have become aware that their own traditions and religions do not have the ability to satisfy their conscience. At the same time the natural thirst to worship God and to search for a religion has not been entirely quenched and does not leave them in peace. As such they are in search of a religion that is free from all sorts of superstitions and corrupt beliefs and whose spiritual power can provide them with satisfying nourishment. It is in keeping with this human search for the path that can satisfy their spiritual quest that one can speculate about the future human society's movement towards discovering the truth about Islamic knowledge and the permanence of its ordinances. At that point it will become evident to them that the only creed which can respond positively to the inner needs and guarantee physical and mental happiness is Islam.
Unfortunately we are not well equipped both in terms of courage and means to inform the peoples of the world about the Islamic truth and its pure teachings. Nevertheless the people's search for truth on the one hand and the well stipulated ordinances of Islam on the other will ultimately allow the problem to resolve by itself. At such an opportune time peoples of the world will convert to the Islamic faith in the thousands making them a majority.
In addition on the basis of general prevailing conditions at the time of the appearance one can speculate that when the promised Mahdi emerges and presents Islamic truths to the world informing humanity about Islam's revolutionary and reformative aspects large numbers of people will accept Islam. Hence they will save themselves from being killed. For on the one hand they will have perfected their ability to perceive religious truth and on the other they will have witnessed the miracles performed by the Imam of the Age. Moreover they will find the social conditions extraordinary and inexplicable and the call of the leader of the revolution will reach their ears. These circumstances will lead thousands and thousands of people to convert to Islam at the hands of the Mahdi thereby saving themselves from destruction.
As for those who persist in their disbelief after all these signs the Peoples of the Book that is the Jews and the Christians will continue to receive the protection of the Islamic government. Other sinful and corrupt disbelievers will be killed by the universal upholder of justice the Mahdi. The number of the latter group will consequently be insignificant.
The Teachings of Islam Will Be Proclaimed to the World from Qumm
From the hadith-reports related by the ahl al-bayt it appears that in the near future the Shi'i religious establishment having grasped better than ever before the teachings of the ahl al-bayt in matters of faith and practice will come out from its state of disorder regalvanize itself with modern communications technology and begin to reach out to the people all over the world with correct information about the teachings of the Qur'an and Islam. They will reintroduce those Islamic teachings that guarantee human happiness and will emphasize the factors that underscore the eminence and advancement of Islam. In this way they will prepare the way for the appearance of the twelfth Imam (peace be upon him). May those days come soon!
In one of the hadith Imam Sadiq says:
Very soon Kufa will be empty of the believers. [Religious] knowledge will disappear from that region the way a snake disappears from its abode into a hole in the earth [without leaving any trace]. Then it will reappear in the city known as Qumm. That city will become the treasure of religious knowledge and excellence. From there it will spread throughout the world thoroughly eliminating ignorance in matters of religion among the destitute including women [who will participate in this process of learning anew about Islam].
This will happen close to the appearance of our Qa'im. In this way God will make Qumm and its inhabitants a substitute for His proof. If it does not happen so the earth will sink engulfing its inhabitants and there will remain no proof. Religious knowledge will spread across nations from Qumm and God's proof will have been provided to all people in such a way that there will not be a single person on earth who will not have heard about the religion and its wisdom. It will be following this event that our Qa'im will appear. God's punishment and tribulation will be ready for execution because God exacts His revenge only when the people have rejected His proof.
In another place the Imam says:
God made the city of Kufa and its inhabitants to serve as a proof over all other places. He will make Qumm also a proof to serve over other places and through its inhabitants He will make an argument against all those including humans and jinns who reject the proof of His existence. God will not disgrace and humiliate Qumm and its peoples; on the contrary they will always enjoy God's grace and support.
He then went on to say:
The religion and the religious in Qumm being deficient will not draw the attention of the people. Had it not been that they were going to serve as God's proof both the city and its inhabitants would have perished and there would have remained no divine proof for the rest of the world. In addition the heavens would not have remained secure and no warning would have been given to the people. Qumm and its inhabitants will remain immune from all the calamities. There will come a time when Qumm and its residents will become a proof for God's existence for the entire world. This will happen during the occultation of our Qa'im until he appears. If this does not happen then the earth will engulf its inhabitants. God's angels will remove all afflictions and calamities from the people of Qumm. Any oppressor who commits aggression against Qumm will be destroyed by those who fight against these oppressors. Furthermore they will be met with distressful calamity or will encounter a powerful enemy who will keep them occupied. Just as these oppressors would have forgotten remembrance of God God will make them forget Qumm and its inhabitants.Imam 'Ali b. Abi Talib predicted the following about Qumm:
There will be a man from Qumm who will call people towards truth. Some will respond to his call and will rally around him like pieces of iron [that are drawn towards a magnet]. Strong winds will not be able to move them from their place. They will not be tired of warfare and will be fearless. They trust in none but God. At the end the victory is for those who are godfearing. 
Dr. Jalali: You have predicted that Muslims will be in the majority in the future. This speculation is contradicted by some hadith-reports. Thus for instance the Prophet is reported to have said:
There will dawn a time when there will remain nothing but a trace from the Qur'an. And from Islam there will survive only a name. There will be people called Muslims but they will be the farthest of all other people from Islam. They will have well built mosques; but these will be devoid of guidance. 
Mr. Hoshyar: In such hadith-reports the Prophet has not predicted more than a particular detail that there will be a time that the true Islam will disappear and no more than an image of it will remain; and that although there will be Muslims they will be far from the true Islam. However this prediction is also in accord with Muslims being in the majority because it is possible that in spite of being Muslims they will be little affected by the truth and spirituality of Islam. Yet the heavy dust of inconsistency and antiquated traditionalism that will have descended upon Islam will be eradicated by the very existence of the twelfth Imam who will lay the foundation for a renewal of the religious edifice. In this regard it is worth recalling the Prophet's tradition in which he said:
I swear by the One in Whose hand is my life that Islam and Muslims will always be in increase whereas disbelief and those who associate other beings with God will be in decrease.
He then added:
I solemnly declare that wherever night reaches this religion will reach.
It is sufficient to point out that first of all it is predicted that before the twelfth Imam appears the Muslim community will attain a majority status. Second when he appears many people will convert to Islam because the level of human perfection will have advanced to such heights that it will enable people to accept the truth of Islam as many traditions have reported. In the following tradition Imam Baqir has declared:
When our Qa'im rises God will stroke the heads of His creatures with mercy thereby making their mind more flawless and able to realize their dreams by means of it. 
Imam 'Ali b. Abi Talib said:
In the Last Days and the days of calamity and ignorance of the people God will appoint a person and will support him and protect his followers through angels. He will help him through miraculous signs and will give him victory over all the people of the world so that whether they like it or not they will convert to the true religion. He will fill the earth with justice and equity and brilliance and rationality. The distances between places will shrink for him in such a way that no unbeliever will remain except that [the appointed one] will bring [to him] faith and no sinful person will remain except that he will become pious.
"Your Enemies Will Destroy Each Other"
Another matter that helps to resolve the problem raised by Engineer Madani is that the general conditions of the world the advancements in dangerous scientific discoveries and the arms race between the western and eastern nations in addition to a general moral decline in humanity allow us to anticipate that great powers including the Jews and the Christians would engage each other in hostile activities and would destroy a majority of the world's population by means of destructive weapons. Another large group will become the victims of precarious diseases that will surface as a result of human destruction of the natural immune system provided by God in human bodies and in the environment.
A companion of Imam Baqir by the name of 'Abd al-Malik A'yan relates that he once stood up in the Imam's presence and leaning on his two arms wept and said: "I was hopeful that I would witness the period of the Qa'im while there was still some strength left in me." The Imam consoling him said:
Are you not pleased that your enemies are busy with each other [in conflict] while you are safe in your homes? When our Qa'im arises each one of you will gain the energy of forty men. Your heart will become like pieces of iron which if hurled against mountains will break them through. You will be the leaders of the world and its keepers.
In another report Imam Sadiq predicted the following:
Before the Qa'im's rise two deaths will occur: one death red and the other white. These will kill five out of every seven persons. The red death will occur by means of killing and the white through epidemics.
Zurarah b. A'yan Imam Sadiq's close associate on one occasion asked the Imam: "Is the call from heaven [as predicted in the traditions about the Qa'im's rise] a true thing?" The Imam replied: "I declare with solemnity that indeed that will occur just as all the peoples [having heard it] will repeat that [call] on their tongues." He then added: "The Qa'im will not rise until nine out of every ten persons is annihilated."
War Is Inevitable
Dr. Fahimi: Is not it possible that the preparations of the Mahdi's revolution might be done in such a way as to avoid war and bloodshed in establishing his government?
Mr. Hoshyar: As things normally proceed in such events it seems unlikely that this catastrophe can be avoided even when the level of people's thinking changes to the extent that the number of good people increases the oppressors and egotistic persons will still be there in the midst of human society. This group will indisputably be opposed to justice and will never give up their stubborn antagonism against any power. Such people will do anything against the promised Mahdi to protect their vested interests. Moreover they will do anything within their power to demoralize and combat those who support the Imam. To crush the negative influence of this group there is no other solution except warfare and bloodshed. It is for this reason that the hadith-reports from the ahl al-bayt have regarded warfare and bloodshed inevitable.
In one of the traditions Bashir another companion of Imam Sadiq asked the Imam about what the people were saying about the rise of the Mahdi: 'When he rises not even an amount of blood as small as that which is usually allowed to flow during the cupping procedure will be shed.' The Imam retorted that such a thing was impossible:
"Had such a thing been possible then it would have been done for the Prophet (peace be upon him and his progeny). Actually in the battle against the enemy the Prophet's blood flowed as his teeth and his forehead were injured. By God the revolution of the one who will command the affairs [of the Muslim community] will not be accomplished until we sweat on the battlefield and blood is shed." He then wiped his hand on his forehead.
The Mahdi's Defense
Dr. Jalali: I have heard that the Imam of the Age will rise with a sword. This is something that does not seem to be right. The reason is that so far humankind has created and discovered various kinds of weapons to be used on the battlefields. Nuclear proliferation and weapons of mass destruction are recent additions to the array of weaponry in human arsenals. With the use of chemical and biological weapons including remote detonation devices for binary weapons thousands upon thousands of people can be destroyed in one blow. The question arises that with all these weapons existing now how can one imagine that the Mahdi and his soldiers will be triumphant fighting with swords?
Mr. Hoshyar: Yes indeed the subject of the Mahdi's rise with the sword is mentioned in the traditions. Let me cite some examples. Imam Baqir relates:
The Mahdi resembles his forefather the Prophet in that he too will rise with a sword to wipe out tyrants and those who mislead people the enemy of God and the Prophet. He will attain victory by sword and scare and none of his troops (lit. flags) will return [with a defeat].
However the rise with the "sword" is a metaphor for warfare. It indicates that war and bloodshed are part of the official task of the Mahdi. He is commanded by God to make Islam a universal faith and to confront injustice and tyranny even by force and by means of a sword. His circumstance is contrary to his forefathers' careers which did not require them to face the situation in that forceful manner as their charge was limited to admonition and counsel. Consequently "to rise with a sword" does not mean that his weapons of defense are limited to a sword and that he is to restrain himself from using any other kind of weapons. To be sure he too might employ the weapons of the day or even create new weapons to overpower all the known weaponry of his time.
The truth is that our knowledge about the future events of the world is limited; nor do we know in any detailed manner about the future destiny of humankind and the course of its technological enterprise. As such we do not have the right to judge the future on the basis of the past without any evidence. We do not know which country or nation will have a technological and civilizational advantage and superiority over others. It is possible that the weak and divided nations of the Islamic world will wake up and put aside their minor differences to create the universal brotherhood under the mighty banner of tawhid the Unity of God and adopt and implement the Qur'anic guidance as the constitution of the universal Muslim nation. The united Islamic peoples could then utilize their natural resources to their advantage and come out of a self-cultivated laziness and self-imposed isolation to take up the challenge of becoming leaders of human civilization in sciences industry and ethics. They can bring under their control the unleashed and boundless energies of the east and the west in order to channel them into preparing for the final launching of the Mahdi's revolution. At that time the Mahdi can appear and destroy the unjust and tyrannical powers with the help of the mighty forces at his disposal. Furthermore with divine assistance and promises of victory in addition to the extraordinary energy that emanates from the position of the wilayat (the exercise of divinely-ordained sovereignty under the Imamate) he can lay the foundation of a just and equitable government of God on the earth.
At that moment the scientists and scholars whose research made possible the discovery of all the tools and technology will feel sadness and remorse because their discoveries had not been used for the betterment of human life but were instead employed to colonize and to suppress the peoples of the world. Hence in order to give recompense for the abuse of their scientific contributions they will see no other way but to respond to the call of the Mahdi to fight for justice and work for the good of the peoples of the world. We cannot foretell how people in the future will abandon their arrogance and stubbornness come out from their ignorance and work towards the eradication of weapons of mass destruction and the decisive implementation of the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. But all the wealth that is now being used to produce such weapons could then be diverted for the elimination of poverty the advancement of education and the well being of humankind.
The World under the Mahdi
Engineer Madani: Could you give some indications about the conditions that would prevail under the rule of the Mahdi?
Mr. Hoshyar: It is possible to reconstruct the following picture of the future from the traditions related by the ahl al-bayt:
When the promised Mahdi the twelfth Imam (peace be upon him) appears following his victory over the evil forces of the world he will administer the entire world under one Islamic government. He will appoint well-qualified individuals as the governors of different regions of the world with clear instructions and programs for the peaceful and just administration of the region under their governance. The entire earth will flourish under their administration. The Mahdi will distantly oversee the whole earth himself with its widespread regions and extensive affairs accessible to him like the palm of his hand. His disciples and helpers also will observe and talk to him from remote distances. The entire earth will be filled with justice and equity.
People will have become kind and will treat each other with honesty and sincerity. There will be security everywhere as no one will wish to cause harm to another. The economic condition of the people will improve enormously. There will be plenty of rain to cause the earth to become lush with greenery and there will be all kinds of grains and fruits in abundance. Necessary improvements will be introduced in agricultural methods. People will pay more attention to God's presence than to sins. Islam will become the official religion of the world with the call of the Unity of God arising from all corners of the earth.
In the matter of building the roads interesting programs will be introduced. Main roads will be sixty yards wide. In building the roads there will be so much diligence that the mosques standing in the middle will be demolished. Footpaths will adorn the streets. Pedestrians will be asked to cross the roads at the proper pedestrian's crossing; whereas the drivers will be asked to move into the middle. All the windows of the homes that open to the street will be closed. There will be prohibitions against constructing open drains and sewage on the streets. Imposing structures will be demolished. The highly decorative and elevated mosques as well as minarets and the grills separating the leader of the congregational prayers from the worshippers will be destroyed.
During the age of the Mahdi human reason will have reached perfection. General information among people will have advanced to such a degree that women will be able to formulate judicial decisions while at home. Imam Sadiq says:
Knowledge is divided into twenty-seven parts. No more than two parts has been acquired by human beings so far. When our Qa'im arises he will expose the rest of the twenty five parts and distribute it among the people.
People's faith will have attained excellence and their hearts free of malevolence and resentment. Finally let me remind you that all this elaboration has been extracted from pertinent hadith-reports and most of these traditions are rare and reported by a single narrator. Anyone desiring more details can refer to volumes 51 and 52 of Bihar al-anwar volumes 6 and 7 of Ithbat al-hudat and Nu'mani's Kitab al-ghayba.
The Victory of the Prophets
Dr. Jalali: From all the descriptions and excellences that have been related about the Mahdi the twelfth Imam (peace be upon him) in the traditions it would seem that he is more excellent than all the Prophets including the Prophet of Islam (peace be upon him and his progeny). After all none of them succeeded in reforming human society establishing a world government founded upon the Unity of God implementing the divine ordinances in their entirety executing the divine scales of justice perfectly and eliminating injustice and tyranny absolutely. The only person able to accomplish all these tasks is the Mahdi and none other!
Mr. Hoshyar: In reality the reform of human society and the execution of divine laws has been the aspiration of all the Prophets. Each one of these divinely appointed reformers endeavored to accomplish their goal in accord with the possibilities and capacity that were available to them in their particular age and thereby drew the people closer to God. If they had not struggled and made the necessary sacrifices then government based on God's unity would have never taken off. In this sense all these Prophets are participants and have a share in this final success. The accomplishment of the Mahdi should be regarded as the success of all God-worshipping peoples in the line of the Prophets and religious leaders. The Imam's victory is not his own personal victory; rather with the amazing energy of this Imam this will be the victory of truth over falsehood of piety over disbelief. It will be the fulfillment of the past Prophets' promise to their followers and the realization of their ideal for human society.
The accomplishment of the promised Mahdi in truth is the accomplishment of Adam Seth Noah Abraham Moses Jesus Muhammad and all other Prophets (peace be upon them). They were the ones who through their sacrifices and perseverance prepared this highway and to some extent the people's intellect to accept this call. The program was conceived and the struggle begun by the past Prophets. Each one of them provided an example through their own conduct and pushed the level of the people's comprehension of God's purposes until the line reached the Prophet of Islam. He outlined the complete program and provided the comprehensive blueprint for the transformation of the world. At the time of his death he handed that over to his rightful successors the Imams. The Prophet and the Imams then endeavored on this path to execute the divine plan for humanity and in so doing encountered severe opposition and made great sacrifices. Many more years should go by and many more crises and revolutions must be faced by humanity in order for it to mature and become worthy of the government based on tawhid. It will only be then that the last barrier of disbelief and irreligiosity will be surmounted by the astounding energy of the Mahdi (peace be upon him) only then will the dream of humanity materialize.
Hence the promised Mahdi is the executor of the Prophet's plans including those of the past Prophets. His victory is the victory of the revealed religions. God promises victory to David in the Psalms and in one of the passages of the Qur'an revealed to underscore the Mahdi's final accomplishment God reminds Muslims of that promise saying: "We have written in the Psalms that Our righteous servants shall inherit the earth." (Anbiya' 105)
The Mahdi and the New Constitution
Dr. Jalali: I have heard that the twelfth Imam (peace be upon him) will bring a new religion constitution and laws for the people. The present laws of Islam will be abrogated by him. How reliable is this account?
Mr. Hoshyar: The source of this information are the traditions on this subject. Thus to clarify the issue we must cite some of these hadith.
'Abd Allah b. 'Ata' asked Imam Sadiq about the character and conduct of the Mahdi. The Imam said:
He will carry out the same mission that the Prophet did. He will eradicate prevailing innovations just as the Prophet destroyed the foundation of the jahiliyya (pre-Islamic Arab morals) and then rebuild Islam afresh.
In another hadith Abu Khadija relates from Imam Sadiq who said:
When the Qa'im rises he will come with a new commission just as the Prophet in the beginning of Islam called the people to a new commission.
In still another hadith Imam Sadiq says:
When the Qa'im emerges he will come with a new commission a new book a new conduct and a new judgement which will be strenuous for the Arabs. His work is nothing but to fight and no one [among the disbelievers] will be spared. He will not be afraid of any blame in the execution of his duty. 
The Conduct of the Mahdi
However these and other traditions point to an important factor in Mahdi's behavior -- that his conduct will be based on that of his forefather the Prophet. He will defend the religion and the Qur'an that were given to the Prophet. For instance the Prophet is reported to have said: "One of my ahl al-bayt will rise and will act upon my tradition and my custom." And he said: "The Qa'im among my children will have my name and my patronymic. He will possess my features and will follow my conduct. He will command the people to my obedience and to my law; and he will call them to the Book of my Lord."
In another tradition he said:
My twelfth descendant will disappear in such a way that he will not be seen at all. There will come a time when there shall remain nothing but a name from Islam. And there shall remain nothing but a trace from the Qur'an. At that time God will permit him to revolt and through him God will reinforce Islam and revive it.
In still another hadith the Prophet said: "Mahdi is from my family and will fight for my tradition just as I fought for the Qur'an."
As one can observe these traditions clearly indicate that the twelfth Imam's agenda and his plan of action are to propagate Islam and to revive the importance of the Qur'an. In order to execute the teachings of the Prophet he will strive with force. Hence if there is any ambiguity in the earlier traditions cited in this section the above traditions help clarify them. Over all the traditions should be interpreted as follows:
During the occultation innovations will appear in the religion and the ordinances of the Qur'an and the teachings of Islam will be interpreted in accordance with people's likes and dislikes. As a result many teachings and laws will be forgotten as if they were never even a part of Islam. When the Mahdi appears he will invalidate these innovations and will restore the ordinances of God as they were when they were commanded. He will institute the penal laws of Islam without any leniency. Evidently such a program will be perceived by the people something new.
Imam Sadiq in another hadith has made the aforementioned role of the Mahdi explicit: "When the Qa'im rises he will emulate the conduct of the Prophet except that he will elaborate the traditions of Muhammad (peace be upon him and his progeny)."
Fadl b. Yasar heard Imam Baqir saying: "When our Qa'im rises he will face so much difficulty from the people that even the Prophet during the period of jahiliyya did not face." Fadl asked: "Why should that be so?" The Imam said:
When the Prophet was appointed people worshipped stones and wood. However when our Qa'im arises people will interpret the ordinances of God against his interpretation and will argue with him and dispute by means of the Qur'an. By God the justice of the Qa'im will enter inside their homes just as the heat and the cold enter them.
The Freshness of the Explanations Offered by the Mahdi
People having abandoned the absolute principles and fundamental teachings of Islam merely follow the outward forms of religion and regard those to be sufficient. These are the people who besides the five daily obligatory prayers the fasting of Ramadan and avoidance of external pollution (najasat) know nothing of Islam. Besides some of them have limited religion to the mosque and hence its reality has very little impact upon their actions and behavior. In the life outside the mosque that is in the market place or at work there is no trace of their Islam. They do not regard ethical behavior and moral precepts to be part of Islam. They give no importance eschewing to immoral conduct and make an excuse of not following moral guidelines since there is dispute about the obligatoriness and the prohibitions of certain requirements. They go as far as turning the prohibitions of the law through trickery into something permissible. They also shun their responsibility for paying the dues that are imposed by the law on them. In other words they are engaged in interpreting the religion according to their desires.
When it comes to the Qur'an they think it sufficient to pay attention to its formal recitation and to respect the conventions in that connection. Hence when the twelfth Imam appears it is obvious that he will ask them as to why they have abandoned the essence of religion and have interpreted the Qur'an and the hadith to fit their own preferred meanings. Why have they left the truth of Islam while being satisfied with mere outward adherence to it? Why have they not sought to conform their character and their actions with the true spirit of Islam? Why have they twisted the meanings of the religion to accord with their own personal avarice? Since they pay so much attention to the proper recitation of the Qur'an they should also put its directives into action. The twelfth Imam has the right to ask: "My grandfather Imam Husayn did not get killed for the sake of mourning. Why have you forsaken my grandfather's goal and destroyed it?"
The Imam will ask them to learn the Islamic social and moral teachings and apply them in their everyday lives. They should avoid the forbidden acts and take care of their financial obligations without making flimsy excuses. They should also keep in mind that remembering the merits of the ahl al-bayt and weeping for their suffering can never substitute for the zakat and khums and taking care of one's debts. Nor can they substitute for such sinful behavior as taking interest and bribes cheating others and treating them with dishonesty. They should recognize that weeping and sighing for Imam Husayn can never substitute for having ill-treated orphans and widows. More importantly they should not limit piety to the mosque; rather they should seek participation in the society and carry out the duty of commanding the good and forbidding the evil and fight the innovations that have crept into Islam.
Certainly such a religion would seem new and difficult to these people and they might not even consider it to be Islam because they have imagined Islam to be something else. These people used to think that the progress and greatness of Islam lay in decorating the mosques and in constructing tall minarets. If the twelfth Imam says: "The greatness of Islam is righteous action honesty trustworthiness keeping promises avoiding forbidden acts " this would appear to them altogether new! They used to assume that when the Imam appears he will make amends for all the actions of the Muslims and will retire with them in the corner of a mosque. But if they witness that blood is dripping from the Imam's sword and that he is calling people to jihad and to command the good and forbid the evil and that he is killing the unjust worshippers and returning the goods they have stolen to their rightful owners such actions of the Imam they will indeed find new!
Imam Sadiq relates:
When our Qa'im arises he will call people anew to Islam guiding them to the old thing from which people have turned away. He will be called Mahdi because he will guide people to the thing from which they have been separated. He will be called Qa'im because he will be commanded to establish the truth.
In short there is a total difference between the assumed Mahdi and his agenda and the true Mahdi and his role. It is for this reason that since his actions will not be approved by the people they will desert him in the beginning. However since they will find no one else who can deliver them they will submit to him. Imam Sadiq says:
I can witness the Qa'im wearing the particular garment and taking out the letter of the Prophet sealed with a golden seal and after breaking the seal he reads aloud to the people. The people disperse from him as the sheep do from the shepherd.
And no one besides his vizier and eleven chiefs remain with him. Then people begin to search for a reformer everywhere. But since they do not find anyone besides him who can help them they rush towards him. By God I know what the Qa'im is telling them which they refuse to acknowledge. 
The Mahdi and Abrogation of the Ordinances
Dr. Fahimi: If I recall you had said earlier that the Mahdi is not the lawgiver and neither is he the abrogator of the law. This statement of yours does not agree with the substance of the following tradition:
Imam Sadiq said:
Two cases of bloodshed are permissible in Islam. But no one executes the divine ordinance in those two cases until God sends the Qa'im from the ahl al-bayt who can execute God's injunction in those cases without requiring any witnesses: one is the case of a married man committing adultery who will be stoned by him; and the other is the case of a person refusing to pay the zakat.
In another tradition the Imam said: "When the Qa'im from the family of Muhammad appears he will judge among people without requiring witnesses in the manner of David and Solomon."
These and other such traditions imply that Islamic ordinances will be abrogated by the Imam who will substitute for them new ordinances. By holding such beliefs you are actually proving the prophethood of the Mahdi even though you do not call him a prophet!
Mr. Hoshyar: First of all allow me to point out that the source of such beliefs consists of rare traditions reported by a single narrator. Second I do not see any problem with the proposition that God may reveal a law to the Prophet and inform him that the law will be applicable to him and his followers until the time when the Qa'im appears. When the twelfth among his descendants appears he should follow a second injunction. The Prophet also informs about this arrangement to his successor until the information reaches the last Imam. In such a case the ordinance is not abrogated and the Imam does not introduce a new ruling that was revealed to him. Rather the first injunction was already limited in time and the Prophet was already informed about the second one.
Thus for instance social expediency required that the judge should confine his judgement to an objective proof seeking witnesses and an oath. The Prophet and the Imams were also required to follow the same procedure in their administration of justice. However when the Mahdi appears and establishes the Islamic government he is required to decide the case on the basis of his knowledge. Thus this latter ordinance was already part of Islamic judisprudence awaiting execution after the appearance of the Mahdi.
Is It Not Possible that the Mahdi Has Already Appeared?
Dr. Jalali: We recognize with you the fundamental belief about the Mahdi. Yet how do we know that he has not appeared already? From the early days of Islamic history up until now there have been many individuals from different parts of the world both belonging to the Quraysh and non-Quraysh who have arisen with the claim to Mahdiism. Interestingly they found supporters among the people and have even left their legacy in the sects that were named after them. In fact some of them came to power and established dynasties that lasted for some time. Here we are awaiting the appearance of the Mahdi and in all likelihood one of the pretenders to Mahdiism might have been a true Mahdi about which we have no information!
Mr. Hoshyar: As we have detailed in our previous discussions we do not believe in an unidentifiable Mahdi whose characteristics are unknown to us so that we might make an error in recognizing him. On the contrary the Prophet and the Imams (peace be upon them) who informed people about this fundamental expectation and the existence of the Mahdi provided all the detailed characteristics and qualifications of the Mahdi to remove all doubts and ambiguities about his identity. The following hadith is the summary of such a description of the future Mahdi:
The Mahdi's name is Muhammad and his patronymic is Abu al-Qasim. His mother was a slave-girl by the name of Narjis Sayqal and Sawsan. He will be a Hashimite from the descendants of Imam Husayn and a direct offspring of Imam Hasan 'Askari. He was born in the year 256/868 or 255/867 in the city of Samarra in Iraq. He has two forms of occultation: one short the other long. The second occultation will be prolonged to such an extent that many people will doubt his very existence. His age will be very long. The mission will begin in Mecca. He will launch his revolution with a sword and will annihilate all the oppressors and disbelievers. All the Peoples of the Book and Muslims will submit to his authority. He will establish a universal Islamic government on earth will thoroughly uproot the forces of injustice and tyranny and will replace these with justice and equity. Islam will become the universal faith and the Mahdi will expend his energy to spread it peacefully amongst all. Such are the traits and functions of the Mahdi for whom the Muslims are awaiting.
Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad Shirazi "the Bab"
Mr. Hoshyar: Now Dr. Jalali let me ask you a question. Among all those who have claimed to be the Mahdi so far have you come across anyone in whom all these characteristics that we have detailed above finds expression so that his claim could be ascertained as a possibility?
For example a person who arose in one of the cities of Iran claiming Mahdiism was neither the son of Imam Hasan 'Askari nor had he gone into occultation for a long time or fought any battle against the unjust rulers or established a universal Islamic government to fill the earth with justice and equity. It is remarkable that he did not raise his hand even a little to stop people from doing wrong. Moreover not only did he not spread Islam all over the world he actually abrogated all its laws and established a new creed in its place. He did not possess any profound knowledge nor did he perform any astounding task. And towards the end of his career in spite of the fact that he repented and displayed remorse he was executed. Can any rational person endowed with intelligence assume that such an individual could be the promised Mahdi of the Muslims?
The story of this pseudo-Mahdi from the city of Shiraz is no different from one related in the Mathnavi of Jalaluddin Rumi about a man from Qazvin who claimed to be strong but could not stand the pain that was caused by someone poking a needle on his arm to tattoo a lion that he had desired. The choice of a lion as Rumi indicates was intended to show off his toughness. However at each stage of tattooing this pseudo-strong man from Qazvin was willing to omit drawing parts of the lion's image that would require the tattooer to poke his needle more frequently and deeper. These requests to omit major parts of the lion's body led the tattooer to poke fun at his client:
Who has seen a lion without a tail a head or a stomach?
When did God ever create such a lion? If you don't have the strength to bear the poking of the needle Don't desire such a brave lion [as a symbol of your strength].
One of the interesting episodes connected with Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad Shirazi is that before the claim to being the Mahdi and Qa'im had got into his head he had written a book entitled: Tafsir-i sura-yi kawthar (Commentary on the Sura Kawthar). In this book he reported traditions about the promised Mahdi which were not congruent with his own later claim of Mahdiism. Later on this issue became a source of aggravation and nuisance for him and his followers.
In this book he writes:
Musa b. Ja'far Baghdadi related that he heard from Imam Hasan 'Askari who said: 'I see you [in the future] disputing with each other in the matter of my successor. Nonetheless be aware that whoever acknowledges all the Imams after the Prophet and rejects my son will resemble someone who will acknowledge all the Prophets but will deny the prophethood of Muhammad (peace be upon him and his progeny). And anyone who denies the Prophet of God will resemble someone who has denied all of the Prophets. The reason is that obedience to the last one among us is like obedience to the first one among us; and denial of the last one among us is like the denial of the first. Know that my son will have an occultation and all the people except a few who will be protected by God will fall into doubt.'
Then he quotes another tradition as follows:
Imam Rida told Di'bil: "Imam following me is my son Muhammad; after Muhammad it will be his son 'Ali; after 'Ali it will be his son Hasan and following Hasan it will be his son Hujjat and Qa'im who should be awaited during his occultation and obeyed when he appears. If there remains but a day in the age of the world God will prolong it until the Qa'im arises and fills the earth with justice and equity just as it is filled with injustice and tyranny. As to when he will appear this would be to inform about the time of his rise whereas our forefathers have reported from 'Ali who related it from the Prophet who was asked: 'O Messenger of God when will the Qa'im from your descendants arise?' He replied: 'His situation resembles that of the Day of Resurrection [about whose timing no one but God can reveal]. However the matter is of grave importance both in the heaven and on earth and accordingly will happen all of a sudden.'" 
It is evident that a number of things are resolved in these two traditions: first Qa'im and Mahdi are the direct offspring of Imam Hasan 'Askari; second he will have a lengthy period of occultation; third when he appears he will fill the earth with justice and equity; and fourth no one can fix the time for his rise.
Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad's Acknowledgement of the Hidden Imam's Existence
In his book on the commentary of Sura Kawthar Sayyid Muhammad 'Ali acknowledged the existence of the Hidden Imam and wrote about the signs and indications of that existence. Thus for instance he writes:
There is no doubt about the existence of the Hidden Imam. The reason is that if he did not exist no one else would have existed. As such this matter is as clear as the sun in the sky. The problem is that the necessary corollary of doubt in his existence is doubt in God's power. Anyone who doubts the existence of God is a disbeliever. . . . As for the Muslims and the believers among the followers of the Twelve Imams the Imamiyya the period of his birth is proven (may my spirit and the spirit of all those in the realm of the spiritual beings -- malakut -- be a sacrifice for his excellency!). Moreover his short occultation and the miracles that took place in those days as well as the signs that were given to his deputies are also proven beyond any doubt. . . . He (the twelfth Imam) is a righteous offspring. His patronymic is Abu al-Qasim. He is the one invested with God's command (al-qa'im bi-amr allah) the proof of God's existence for God's creatures the remaining one (baqiyyat allah) among the servants of God the Mahdi who will guide people to the mysterious matters. But I do not like to mention his name except the way the Imam ['Askari] has mentioned it that is mim ha mim da. There are texts in this regard directly received from the [twelfth] Imam (peace be upon him). The Imam himself has written the note in which he says: "God's curse be upon the one who mentions me by my name in public.". . . The Master of the Age (wali 'asr) will have two [forms of] occultation. During the lesser occultation he had trustworthy and intimate deputies and agents. The period of the lesser occultation lasted for seventy four years and some days. The deputies of the respected master (may our spirits be a sacrifice for him!) include: 'Uthman b. Sa'id 'Amri and his son Muhammad b. 'Uthman Husayn b. Ruh and 'Ali b. Muhammad Samarri.
In another place in the same book he writes about his own experience of having seen the twelfth Imam in Mecca:
One day I was busy praying in the holy mosque of Mecca on the side of the Yamani pillar [of the Ka'ba]. I noticed a well built and good looking young man who was deeply involved in performing the circumambulation (tawaf). He had a white turban on his head and a woolen cloak on his shoulder. He was with the merchants' group from Fars. There was no more than a few steps of distance between us. All of a sudden a thought came to my mind that he could be the Master of the Command (sahib al-amr). But I was embarrassed to go closer to him. When I finished my prayers I did not find him. Nevertheless I am not so sure that he was the Master of the Command.
Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad and the Traditions about Fixing of the Time
The following hadith also appears in the commentary on Sura Kawthar:
Abu Basir reported that he asked Imam Sadiq: "May my life be a sacrifice for you! When will the Qa'im arise?" He replied: "O Abu Muhammad we the ahl al-bayt cannot fix the time of his appearance. Moreover the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his progeny) said: 'Those who fix the time for the rising [of the Qa'im] are liars.'"
This and other traditions of its kind make amply clear that the Imams themselves never fixed the time of the appearance and they falsified anyone else who tried to do that. However the followers of the afore-mentioned Sayyid from Shiraz have ignored these clear indications and contrary to the textual proof to that effect provided by their leader have searched and found a weak tradition attributed to Abu Labid Makhzumi and through a far-fetched and mysterious interpretation extracted from it the year of the Sayyid's appearance in 1256 AH/1840 CE.
The books that have been written in refutation of the claims made by this particular faction based on the tradition reported by Abu Labid are far too numerous to be mentioned here. Moreover any further discussion about the subject would be a digression from our topic of discussion at this time. Suffice it to say that according to the hadith of Abu Basir also relied upon by Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad in his commentary any tradition that fixes the exact time for the appearance of the Qa'im must be rejected as false. As such its inclusion as evidence is not permissible whether it is the hadith related by Abu Labid or by someone else. The following hadith also appears in the commentary on Sura Kawthar:
Imam Sadiq has related in a lengthy tradition saying: "The occultation of our Qa'im will be denied by the umma. Some will say without any knowledge: The Imam was never born; others will say: he was born but he died. Still others will become disbelievers and will say: The eleventh Imam had no offspring at all. Some will spread factionalism in the community by what they say and will go beyond the twelve Imams and will count thirteen or more Imams. There will be those who will cause God's anger to engulf them by saying: The spirit of the Qa'im is speaking through another person." 
What Do the Sayyid's Followers Say?
In spite of all these clear affirmations in Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad's commentary on Sura Kawthar of which we cited some examples we do not know what his followers believe. If they regard him the promised Mahdi and the Qa'im this belief not only does not conform with the teachings of the ahl al-bayt it also goes against the Sayyid's own affirmations. The reason is that he himself regards the direct descendant of Imam Hasan 'Askari whom he calls mim ha mim da as the Qa'im and the Mahdi. He also introduces his patronymic as Abu al-Qasim regards his short and long forms of occultation necessary and provides the names of his special deputies. Finally he relates his encounter with the young man in the sacred mosque of Mecca whom he thought to be the Hidden Imam.
If the followers of the Sayyid believe that the spirit of the twelfth Imam has transmigrated into the Sayyid's body and that he is the manifestation of the Qa'im then even this belief has no validity. First of all it must be pointed out that such a tenet leads to the belief in the incarnation and transmigration of souls. Both these are proven to be false in Islam. Moreover this belief is in direct contradiction with the hadith from Imam Sadiq which the Sayyid himself has cited. The Imam in this hadith says: "There will be those who will cause God's anger to engulf them by saying: The spirit of the Qa'im is speaking through another person."
The Sayyid Repudiated Any Attribution of Prophethood and Babism
However if his followers believe that he was a prophet or a bab ("gate " meaning mediator between the Hidden Imam and his community) then even this attribution has been declined by him. In the commentary on Sura Kawthar he writes:
Those who say that "Remember the name of Thy Lord" means that he himself (i.e. Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad) has actually claimed to have received revelation and the Qur'an have indeed become disbelievers. Moreover those who say that the verse means that he has claimed to be the bab of the Remnant of God (the twelfth Imam) have also become disbelievers. O God you are my witness that [I declare] any one who claims to be divine or to possess the wilayat or who has received the Qur'an and the revelation or who has omitted or altered anything in Your religion has become an unbeliever. I certainly seek to disassociate from such people. You are my witness that I have not claimed to be the bab.
To be sure when the Sayyid composed his commentary he had no intention of putting forward any messianic claims. He simply considered himself a learned person and sensed pain when he saw himself confined to the house and found other learned authorities occupied with many tasks in the public life. In this connection he writes:
God has favored me by enlightening my heart. I would like to publicize the religion of God the way it was revealed in the Qur'an and demonstrated in the teachings of the ahl al-bayt.
He was troubled by the false messianic claims ascribed to him and took pains to decline them. Later on he realized that the absurdity of the people was beyond imagination. Not only did they accept whatever he said they also added to it something more. It was at that point in his career that his proclivity towards the messianic role of the twelfth Imam became firm in his mind and he proclaimed himself to be the Qa'im.
The Bayan and Messianic Claim
In chapter seven the second unit of his Bayan the Sayyid writes:
Since the appearance of the Qa'im of the family of Muhammad is precisely the same as the emergence of the Messenger of God he will not appear until and unless he manifests the fruits of Islam as deduced from the Qur'anic verses that have been implanted in the hearts of the people. There is no way to deduce the fruits of Islam except by faith in him and confirmation of his status. Now that it has borne fruits to the contrary he has been made manifest in the midst of Islam and everyone proclaims Islam in relation to him while they situate him groundlessly in Maku.
We have no intention of investigating this new creed in any detail so as to refute it and demonstrate its absurdities. Much has been written on this subject and our readers can refer to these works. Nor do we intend to examine each and every claim to Mahdiism that has been made throughout the history of Islam or to investigate their claims and analyze critically the proofs produced to support them. These discussions interesting as they may be go beyond the specific scope of these sessions.
Let me reiterate that the promised Mahdi has been sufficiently introduced and described in the authenticated traditions and possesses an intelligible and unique personality understood in the minds of the Shi'a. If they come across such a person who fits into all the characterizations found in the reliable hadith-reports then they should submit to his authority. If on the contrary they discover that the person is a pseudo-Mahdi then they must absolutely reject him. Those who have so far claimed this messianic position have fallen far short of sustaining such a title. In order to prove their messianic claim it is obvious that they cannot resort to rare and doubtful traditions transmitted by single narrators and interpret them to their advantage. This method of establishing a messianic claim is insufficient simply because of the critical role of the Qa'im in restoring God's religion to its pure unadulterated meaning. No single tradition can compete in reliability and authenticity with already accredited traditions.
False Claims and the Existence of a Followership
Engineer Madani: If the claims of these pseudo-Mahdis were meaningless and false why would they attract such a staunch followership?
Mr. Hoshyar: To become a believer in and an adherent of a person does not prove that person's truthfulness because in the world there have always existed false beliefs and religions and staunch believers in those religions. The perseverance and sacrifice demonstrated by ill-informed and simple people cannot be taken as a proof of the religion's and the leader's truthfulness. Even a cursory glance at the history of religions will reveal this general observation.
For instance at this time in history when human beings have made great strides in rational and scientific development there are millions of people in India who worship cows and believe that this animal has an elevated status in the heavens. They regard killing a cow and consuming its meat a prohibition and consider disrespect to it as sinful. The Hindus in India are willing to defend the cow at a great price. One of the causes of conflict between Hindus and Muslims in India is the slaughtering of the cow for food which is permitted in Islam.
Such examples are plentiful in the history of world religions. Hence it should come as little surprise to see human beings following all kinds of creeds and religions false or true.
I believe we have covered the majority of the fundamental aspects related to the belief in the Mahdi in Islam in general and among the Shi'a in particular. Since there are no more issues to discuss we might consider bringing our sessions on this subject to a close.
Dr. Jalali: I agree that we do not have any other related questions about the subject.
Dr. Emami: I must say that these sessions were extremely beneficial for my understanding of the Shi'i beliefs. I wish we could continue to learn some more. However it is appropriate to bring the sessions connected with our subject on the Mahdi the Universal Just Ruler of the World to an end.
Let me take this opportunity to thank you all. May God hasten deliverance through the appearance of the Supreme Remnant of God the twelfth Imam and may He make us all the servants of Islam and the helpers of the Imam.
Wassalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh!
And peace be upon you and God's mercy and His blessing!
(1). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 370.
(2). Ibid. p. 327.
(3). The phrase kuffar-i ghayr-i kitabi refers to the disbelievers who are neither Christian nor Jewish nor Zoroastrian. These latter are regarded in the Shari'a as muwahhidun i.e. monotheists. Tr.
(4). Ithbat al-hudat Vol. 7 p. 215 247.
(5). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 345.
(6). Bihar al-anwar Vol 52 p. 376 381.
(7). Nu'mani Kitab al-ghayba p.237.
(8). Bihar al-anwar Vol 52 p. 340.
(9). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 390.
(10). Ibid. p. 340.
(11). Ibid. Vol. 51 p. 47.
(12). Ibid. Vol. 52 p. 378.
(13). Safinat al-bihar hadith related under 'Qumm.'
(15). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 60 p. 216.
(16). Ibid. Vol. 52 p. 190.
(17). Ibn 'Asakir Ta'rikh (Damascus edition 1329) Vol. 1 p. 87.
(18). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 328.
(19). Ithbat al-hudat Vol. 7 p. 49.
(20). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 335.
(21). Ithbat al-hudat Vol. 7 p. 401.
(22). Bihar al-anwarVol. 52 p. 244.
(23). Ibid. p. 358.
(24). Ibid. Vol. 51 p. 218.
(25). Tabari Dala'il al-imama (Najaf edition 1369) p. 249.
(26). Bihar al-anwar Vol 52 p. 336.
(27). Ibid. p. 352.
(28). Ithbat al-hudat Vol. 7 p. 110.
(29). Ibid. p. 83.
(30). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 51 p. 82.
(31). Ithbat al-hudat Vol. 7 p. 52.
(32). Muntakhab al-athar p. 98.
(33). Yanabi' al-muwadda Vol. 2 p. 179.
(34). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 347.
(35). Ithbat al-hudat Vol. 7 p. 86.
(36). Kashf al-ghumma Vol. 3 p. 264; Mufid Irshad p. 240 343.
(37). Bihar al-anwar Vol. 52 p. 326.
(38). Ibid. p. 325.
(39). Ibid. p. 320.
(40). Nabil Zarandi Talkhis-i ta'rikh pp.135-138.
(41). Tafsir-e sura-yi Kawthar.